For Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs), achieving success is reliant on protecting narrow profit margins. In an industry characterized by intense competition, it is crucial to understand that every single lost cent can have a substantial impact on your overall financial performance. One significant and often hidden factor that can greatly affect profitability is the cost of chargebacks. These chargebacks do not merely represent an immediate loss of revenue; they initiate a series of associated expenses that can diminish margins over time. Have you taken the time to fully comprehend the extent of the financial burden that chargebacks impose on your MVNO?

The Multi-Layered Costs of Chargebacks

When a chargeback occurs, the effects reach far beyond just the immediate impact of losing a single transaction. These often-overlooked costs can accumulate and affect a business significantly:

• Lost Revenue and Bank Fees: Each time a chargeback is initiated, the business faces the immediate loss of the revenue from that particular sale. In addition to this lost income, financial institutions often impose per-chargeback fees that can increase the financial strain on a business. These fees can add up quickly, particularly for companies that process a large number of transactions in a given timeframe, thereby leading to even greater financial losses.
• Operational Overhead: Dealing with chargebacks is not just a simple matter of accepting the loss; it requires a dedicated payment operations team to manage the complexities involved. This team must invest considerable time and resources into reviewing disputes, investigating each case thoroughly, and determining where to contest chargebacks that may be “first party”. This process can create a substantial operational cost that many businesses may not fully account for in their financial planning.
• The Threat of Network Fines: Businesses need to be aware that if their chargeback rate exceeds the established thresholds set by payment networks, they may incur significant fines. Then, the business must submit a plan to the payment network for getting chargebacks under control. Penalty costs of remediating excessive chargebacks can further squeeze profit margins that are already tight.

Lost Sales and Marketing Spend

One of the most overlooked costs that MVNOs face is related to ineffective management of fraud or chargeback risk. This cost is the marketing investment or opportunity cost of sales lost to inaccurate risk flagging. Payment gateways or banks have the capability to label certain transactions as high-risk, which can lead to their rejection. MVNOs who invest in ineffective fraud management technology can see the same challenges. While it is necessary to accurately identify fraudulent transactions, there is always the issue of false positives. These are legitimate sales that are mistakenly flagged as risky, and this can result in a significant financial impact for a business.

• Loss of Revenue and Profitability: The immediate and most noticeable effect of a false positive is the forfeiture of revenue, along with the profit that a successfully completed sale would have produced. This situation constitutes a pure opportunity cost, as the business not only misses out on cash flow but also suffers from a decrease in margins due to the unrealized sale.
• Reputational Harm: Blocking legitimate transactions not only forfeits the initial marketing and sales investment made to acquire that customer, turning it into a complete loss, but can also backfire significantly. Imagine a potential customer, ready to complete a purchase, suddenly feeling insulted by the MVNO brand. This negative experience can easily drive them to a competitor, and even worse, lead to negative word-of-mouth and overall reputational damage.

Sources of Chargebacks

Chargebacks, a common issue that takes place in financial transactions, have a variety of causes that can contribute to their occurrence. It is important to recognize that chargebacks do not always arise from dishonest or criminal behavior. Instead, they can emerge from multiple sources, each with its own implications:

• Genuine Fraud: This type of chargeback involves actual criminal actions, where an individual makes unauthorized purchases without the rightful owner’s consent. These instances typically require thorough investigation and may involve law enforcement.
• First-Party Fraud: First-party fraud isn’t just about customers changing their minds. Often dubbed “friendly fraud,” it involves deliberate deception where customers falsely claim non-authorization after consuming the product or service to avoid payment. This type of fraud is difficult to detect because fraudsters use their own legitimate information – real email, device, and consistent location data – making traditional fraud signals ineffective. Unlike account takeovers, everything appears normal. While disputes are possible with evidence, the initial detection remains a significant hurdle.

Viewing Each Transaction as an Income Statement

To fully understand the effects of chargebacks on your business, it is helpful to think of every individual transaction as a separate income statement. In this framework, the lost revenue from chargebacks can be viewed as the top line, or the initial amount earned from that sale. Additionally, when we analyze the potential profit margin, which includes the costs associated with goods sold and other operating expenses, we find that these profits effectively disappear due to the chargeback.

The Importance of High-Value Goods in Chargebacks

The cost associated with goods sold is an important factor that greatly influences the overall effect of a chargeback. This is particularly relevant for mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) that engage in selling hardware products such as smartphones. When an MVNO faces a chargeback related to a new, high-end smartphone like the iPhone, the financial repercussions can be much greater because the price tag on such devices is relatively high. In contrast, although a chargeback involving prepaid wireless minutes can still have negative consequences, the immediate financial impact tends to be lower because the cost of offering those minutes is practically negligible.

Small Telcos, Big Impact

The financial burden of chargeback fees can significantly impact smaller mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs). These smaller organizations often lack the negotiating power that larger corporations possess, which allows the bigger players to secure reduced rates on bank fees related to chargebacks. Unfortunately, this advantage is typically out of reach for smaller companies, making it more challenging for them to manage costs effectively.

Vesta: Your Partner in Preventing Profit-Eroding Chargebacks

At Vesta, we take pride in our fundamentally different approach to payment processing, setting ourselves apart from traditional payment gateways. Our extensive experience spans over 25 years in the telecommunications industry, during which we have processed more than $50 billion in payments. This substantial experience has equipped us with a deep and unparalleled understanding of the specific chargeback patterns that are often found within the Telco sector.

• Slash False Positives: We utilize advanced, AI-powered models that are finely tuned to recognize the unique nuances of the Telco industry. This allows us to dramatically reduce the incidence of legitimate sales being incorrectly identified as risky, which in turn helps recover lost revenue that would have been otherwise irretrievably lost and eliminates the wasted marketing spend that often accompanies such false positives.
• Eliminate Network Fine Risks: Our robust control methods are meticulously designed to maintain your chargeback rates well below the critical thresholds that trigger costly fines from network providers. By effectively managing these chargeback rates, we work to protect your finances from unexpected penalties and protect your bottom line.
• Deflect Remaining Chargeback Costs: Vesta employs a unique approach that effectively absorbs the costs associated with lost revenue and chargeback fees, even those related to the small percentage of chargebacks that might still occur. This means that there is no financial risk for Vesta customers when it comes to these particular transactions, allowing you to conduct business with peace of mind.
• Streamline Payment and Chargeback Management: Vesta actively takes on the responsibility of challenging first-party chargebacks. This alleviates your valuable payment operations team’s burden and allows them to redirect their focus and energy toward other critical tasks that require their expertise.
• Empower Strategic Risk Management: For our most advanced customers, we offer precise tools that facilitate the strategic management of mid-risk transactions. This capability empowers you to approve potentially high-value or high-margin customers who may have otherwise been flagged incorrectly, optimizing for customer lifetime value and ultimately enhancing your business’s profitability.

Take action to prevent chargebacks that could have been avoided, as they can significantly impact the profitability of your Mobile Virtual Network Operator (MVNO) business. Vesta provides a reliable solution that is tailored specifically for this industry, which can help protect your revenue and improve your overall financial performance. By implementing Vesta, you can work towards safeguarding your profit margins and ensuring that your business remains successful and financially stable.

Request A Demo

Don’t let payment fraud erode your hard-earned margins. Discover how our cutting-edge revenue orchestration platform can protect your revenue and boost your bottom line. Request your free demo today!